Marketplace sellers usually compare channels by revenue. That is a mistake. A $30 sale on Amazon, a $30 sale on TikTok Shop, and a $30 sale on Shopee do not produce the same profit once commission, fulfillment, ads, creator fees, shipping subsidies, payment charges, discounts, and returns are included.
The better question is simple: if the same product sold on several marketplaces, which channel would leave the most cash after every variable cost? That is what the Marketplace Profit Calculator is built to answer.
Why Marketplace Profit Comparison Matters
Revenue hides too much. Gross margin hides too much. Even contribution margin can mislead if you do not separate product-level costs from marketplace-specific costs. Amazon might have steadier conversion but higher fulfillment and PPC pressure. TikTok Shop might have strong volume but creator commission and ads can consume margin quickly. Shopee and Lazada might look cheaper until vouchers, shipping programs, and local payment fees are added. Shopify has lower marketplace friction, but customer acquisition and payment processing still matter.
A comparison calculator forces every channel to compete on the same product assumptions.
The Inputs That Matter Most
Start with product-level inputs: selling price, COGS, packaging, base shipping, ad cost per order, return rate, and expected units per month. Then edit marketplace-level assumptions: commission, payment fee, fulfillment fee, referral fee, affiliate commission, fixed per-order fee, and other marketplace costs.
The calculator is useful because every preset is editable. Treat the defaults as planning assumptions, not official fee schedules.
How to Read the Results
| Metric | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Net profit per order | Whether the sale is worth making |
| Profit margin | How much room you have for errors |
| ROI | Whether inventory capital is working hard enough |
| Monthly profit | Whether the channel deserves focus |
| Break-even price | How low you can discount before profit disappears |
Do not crown a marketplace winner from one metric. A channel with the best margin but weak demand might not be your best launch channel. A lower-margin channel with faster inventory turns may still be attractive.
A Practical Workflow
Run four passes. First, create a base case with your normal price and cost assumptions. Second, create a conservative case with higher ad cost and return rate. Third, create a promotion case with lower price or seller-funded coupons. Fourth, create channel-specific cases: affiliate commission for TikTok Shop, PPC pressure for Amazon, shipping and vouchers for Shopee and Lazada, and acquisition cost for Shopify.
Common Mistakes
The most common mistake is treating platform fees as the only difference between marketplaces. TikTok Shop sellers often forget affiliate commission and ads can stack. Amazon sellers often forget storage, returns, coupons, and PPC. Shopify sellers often forget customer acquisition because it does not appear as a marketplace fee.
Related Tools
Start with the Marketplace Profit Calculator. If you sell on one platform first, use the Shopee Profit Calculator, TikTok Shop Profit Calculator, or Amazon FBA Profit Scenario Calculator.
Bottom Line
The best marketplace is not the one with the most traffic. It is the one where your product, fees, acquisition cost, fulfillment model, and return profile still leave room for profit.